Because of the many fractured parts of the Sonic fandom, it can be hard to know what the fanbase "as a whole" wants, or likes.
I've always wanted to see some more definitive data on the fandom's opinions and thought asking the questions myself would probably be the best way to get some answers.
Spoilered bellow are a bunch of questions I'd love to hear Bumblekings opinion on. (I'll be posting the questions on Reddit as well, but please don't double answer.)
Spoiler: show
Current age:
Gender:
Country:
1. What are your personal favorite 3 Sonic games?
2. What are your least favorite 3 Sonic games?
3. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the best?
4. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the worst?
5. What Sonic game do you think is over hyped?
6. What Sonic game was the most disappointing for you?
7. What was your first Sonic game?
8. What is your favorite Sonic gameplay style (2D platformer, “Boost-to-win”, pet sim, RPG, etc.)?
9. What 3 gameplay styles would you like to see the Sonic brand go/return to?
10. Which game incarnation of Sonic (Classic, Modern, Boom) is your favorite (stylistically)?
11. Which incarnation of Sonic would you like to see return, or what new art style would you like to see?
12. How many years have you been a Sonic fan?
13. What Sonic product/people brought you to the franchise?
14. Who are your top 3 favorite Sonic characters?
15. Who are you top 3 Sonic villians?
16. Which 3 game villains (excluding Eggman) would you like to see return?
17. Which 3 enemy types are your favorite (Classic Badnicks, Black Arms, Egg Pawns, etc.)
18. Which, if any, entities (characters, locations, etc.) from other Sonic media would you want to see in the games?
19. What Sonic product lines (games, shows, comics, etc.) do you purchase?
20. What is your favorite Sonic series (Archie, Boom, X, OVA, Sega!Sonic, etc)?
21. How many Sonic games have you played?
22. How many Sonic games have you owned?
23. How many Sonic games have you completed the campaign (All Chaos Emeralds, Final Chapter, etc.)?
24. How many Sonic games have you %100ed (All A Ranks, All Emblems, etc.)?
25. Are you more likely to pre-order/ buy a Sonic game in the month of release, or wait?
26. Which game consoles (including handhelds,) do you own?
27. Which console do you have the most Sonic games for?
28. Have you ever bought a console because of a Sonic game?
29. How do you interpret the Sonic canon (consider the classic games a different universe, believe in the distinction of two worlds in the Sonic universe, consider spin off games non-canon, hold Japanese instruction manuals over American, etc.)?
30. What is your preferred name for Sonic’s world(s) (Earth, Mobius, Planet Freedom, etc)?
31. What is the average amount of time you put into Sonic games? (not in a sitting, but over all)
32. What Sonic have you clocked the most time into (state the amount)?
33. Where do you see the Sonic franchise in ten years?
34. If you had the opportunity to give the Sonic brand to a different developer which would it be, if any?
35. What is your favorite interpretation of Sonic’s characterization?
36. What do you feel is Sonic’s current characterization?
37. How many, if any, Sonic games are in your top ten favorite video games?
38. What has been your favorite Sonic cross-over/cameo to date (TMNT, Spawn, Zelda, etc)?
39. Which Sonic game/show has your favorite Soundtrack?
40. What is are your 3 favorite Sonic song?
41. What other video game franchise would you consider Sonic Team's greatest competition for your attention?
42. What are your top 3 Sonic locations?
43. What 3 Sonic zones would you like to see return in a Sonic game?
44. With what Sonic game have you encountered the most bugs?
45. What Sonic game do you think deserves a (narrative) sequel?
Gender:
Country:
1. What are your personal favorite 3 Sonic games?
2. What are your least favorite 3 Sonic games?
3. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the best?
4. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the worst?
5. What Sonic game do you think is over hyped?
6. What Sonic game was the most disappointing for you?
7. What was your first Sonic game?
8. What is your favorite Sonic gameplay style (2D platformer, “Boost-to-win”, pet sim, RPG, etc.)?
9. What 3 gameplay styles would you like to see the Sonic brand go/return to?
10. Which game incarnation of Sonic (Classic, Modern, Boom) is your favorite (stylistically)?
11. Which incarnation of Sonic would you like to see return, or what new art style would you like to see?
12. How many years have you been a Sonic fan?
13. What Sonic product/people brought you to the franchise?
14. Who are your top 3 favorite Sonic characters?
15. Who are you top 3 Sonic villians?
16. Which 3 game villains (excluding Eggman) would you like to see return?
17. Which 3 enemy types are your favorite (Classic Badnicks, Black Arms, Egg Pawns, etc.)
18. Which, if any, entities (characters, locations, etc.) from other Sonic media would you want to see in the games?
19. What Sonic product lines (games, shows, comics, etc.) do you purchase?
20. What is your favorite Sonic series (Archie, Boom, X, OVA, Sega!Sonic, etc)?
21. How many Sonic games have you played?
22. How many Sonic games have you owned?
23. How many Sonic games have you completed the campaign (All Chaos Emeralds, Final Chapter, etc.)?
24. How many Sonic games have you %100ed (All A Ranks, All Emblems, etc.)?
25. Are you more likely to pre-order/ buy a Sonic game in the month of release, or wait?
26. Which game consoles (including handhelds,) do you own?
27. Which console do you have the most Sonic games for?
28. Have you ever bought a console because of a Sonic game?
29. How do you interpret the Sonic canon (consider the classic games a different universe, believe in the distinction of two worlds in the Sonic universe, consider spin off games non-canon, hold Japanese instruction manuals over American, etc.)?
30. What is your preferred name for Sonic’s world(s) (Earth, Mobius, Planet Freedom, etc)?
31. What is the average amount of time you put into Sonic games? (not in a sitting, but over all)
32. What Sonic have you clocked the most time into (state the amount)?
33. Where do you see the Sonic franchise in ten years?
34. If you had the opportunity to give the Sonic brand to a different developer which would it be, if any?
35. What is your favorite interpretation of Sonic’s characterization?
36. What do you feel is Sonic’s current characterization?
37. How many, if any, Sonic games are in your top ten favorite video games?
38. What has been your favorite Sonic cross-over/cameo to date (TMNT, Spawn, Zelda, etc)?
39. Which Sonic game/show has your favorite Soundtrack?
40. What is are your 3 favorite Sonic song?
41. What other video game franchise would you consider Sonic Team's greatest competition for your attention?
42. What are your top 3 Sonic locations?
43. What 3 Sonic zones would you like to see return in a Sonic game?
44. With what Sonic game have you encountered the most bugs?
45. What Sonic game do you think deserves a (narrative) sequel?
Feel free to ignore any questions you're not interested in answering, and please take note that I intend to record (anonymously) any answers I receive for the purpose of comparing and sharing online.
I'll be collecting the answers in (maybe?) aprox. 2 weeks from now. (longer if more questions are added last second, sooner if everyone who wants to answer has)
Bellow are my answers to the questions:
Spoiler: show
Current age: 19 years young
Gender: Male
Country: Canadian
1. What are your personal favorite 3 Sonic games?
SA2:Battle SADX:Directors Cut and... maybe Sonic CD?
2. What are your least favorite 3 Sonic games?
Secret Rings, Lost World, and Sonic Runners.
3. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the best?
S3&K, CD, and S2.
4. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the worst?
Secret Rings, Lost World, and (tho' Ive never play) Free Riders.
5. What Sonic game do you think is over hyped?
Lost World.
6. What Sonic game was the most disappointing for you?
Sonic 06.
7. What was your first Sonic game?
Sonic Adventure 2 Battle.
8. What is your favorite(s) Sonic gameplay style (2D platformer, “Boost-to-win”, pet sim, RPG, etc.)?
Adventure/06-style 3D Platformer by a long shot. But I've genuinely enjoyed them all other than Secret Ring's "On rails" style.
9. What 3 gameplay styles would you like to see the Sonic brand go/return to?
Adventure-style 3D Platformer (with modern polish of course), Chao Garden sim, and the boost games (maybe with a momentum system).
10. Which game incarnation of Sonic (Classic, Modern, Boom) is your favorite (stylistically)?
Modern, but I do like classic Sonic. Really not a fan of Boom at all.
11. Which incarnation of Sonic would you like to see return, or what new art style would you like to see?
I'd like to see a merging of the Classic and modern styles, like the Sonic Nendoroid
12. How many years have you been a Sonic fan?
10ish years.
13. What Sonic product/people brought you to the franchise?
Only had two tv channels and no game systems as a young kid, so finding a random episode of Sonic X one day lured me into the series, and a copy of the VHS Sonic OVA which I would rent every chance I got- got me hooked.
14. Who are your top 3 favorite Sonic characters?
Shadow, Blaze, and Emerl.
15. Who are you top 3 Sonic villians?
Chaos, Eggman, and Metal Sonic.
16. Which game villain(s) (excluding Eggman) would you like to see return?
Mephlise as Time Eater would be pretty awesome.
17. Which 3 enemy types are your favorite (Classic Badnicks, Black Arms, Egg Pawns, etc.)
Gizoids, E-100s, and GUN mechs.
18. Which, if any, entities (characters, locations, etc.) from other Sonic media would you want to see in the games?
The freedom fighters would be a cool addition to an RPG Sonic game. (Sonic Chronicles 2)
19. What Sonic product lines (games, shows, comics, etc.) do you purchase/participate in?
I buy most games, I've collected the pre-Nu Archie!Sonic comics, I have a few plushes, figures, and the pix'n'love, and I watch all the shows.
20. What is your favorite Sonic series (Archie, Boom, X, OVA, Sega!Sonic, etc)?
OVA.
21. How many Sonic games have you played? 39ish
22. How many Sonic games have you owned? 41ish
23. How many Sonic games have you completed the campaign (All Chaos Emeralds, Final Chapter, etc.)? 28.
24. How many Sonic games have you %100ed (All A Ranks, All Emblems, etc.)? only 1 I believe.
25. Are you more likely to pre-order/ buy a Sonic game in the month of release, or wait? I tend to buy main series in the first month if I have the console. otherwise I wait for Steam sales and discount bins.
26. Which game consoles (including handhelds,) do you own?
DS lite, Gameboy SP, Gamecube, PC, Wii, WiiU.
27. Which console do you have the most Sonic games for?
Gamecube.
28. Have you ever bought a console because of a Sonic game?
No. But when I do buy a system, its Sonic are usually some of the first games I buy.
29. How do you interpret the Sonic canon (consider the classic games a different universe, believe in the distinction of two worlds in the Sonic universe, consider spin off games non-canon, hold Japanese instruction manuals over American, etc.)?
I consider all Sonic games (excluding Boom) to be one canon, which of course requires some fudging.
Generally I hold Japanese canon over Western, main series over spin-offs and hand held, and SA1&2, Battle, Shadow, and Chronicles over all else.
Still trying to wrap my head around the whole "two worlds" debacle. For the time being I'm ignoring it, but I'll eventually sit down and try to plot out the canon with the idea of there being two planets in mind.
30. What is your preferred name for Sonic’s world(s) (Earth, Mobius, Planet Freedom, etc)?
Earth.
31. What is the average amount of time you put into Sonic games? (not in a sitting, but over all)
Under 10. probably about 7.
32. What Sonic have you clocked the most time into (state the amount)?
Both of the Sonic Adventure games I suspect I have over 300 hours.
33. Where do you see the Sonic franchise in ten years?
I see it more-or-less how it is now, whith a mix of good and bad games that keep Sonic alive, but not a big name in gaming.
I also suspect that no-matter how good Sonic games get, the baggage behind the name will mar the series.
34. If you had the opportunity to give the Sonic brand to a different developer which would it be, if any?
Out of curiosity I'd like to see a Nintendo Sonic game, but generally I'd prefer Sonic Team keep the franchise.
35. What is your favorite interpretation of Sonic’s characterization?
I always liked his over-the-top-cheesy 90's cool kid vibe. Sonic OVA probably got him best IMO.
36. What do you feel is Sonic’s current characterization?
I feel that Sonic has lost a great deal of his edge. With his aloof/jerkish behavior being replaced with pure heroism and bad jokes.
37. How many, if any, Sonic games are in your top ten favorite video games?
Sonic Adventure 1&2 for sure.
38. What has been your favorite Sonic cross-over/cameo to date (TMNT, Spawn, Zelda, etc)?
Sonic in Smash Bros.
39. Which Sonic game/show has your favorite Soundtrack?
Unleashed, if I had to pick.
40. What is are your 3 favorite Sonic song (stage music counts)?
Endless Possibilities, Supporting Me, and maybe... Escape from the City?
41. What other video game franchise would you consider Sonic Team's greatest competition for your attention?
Right now, the entire Nintendo Roster.
I've been putting allot of my gaming purchases Into virtual Console games instead of Sonic games missing in my library.
42. What are your top 3 Sonic locations?
43. What 3 Sonic zones would you like to see return in a Sonic game?
44. With what Sonic game have you encountered the most bugs?
Sonic Heroes. I feel like I might be the only person to have had an absolutely glitch-ridden copy of this game.
45. What Sonic game do you think deserves a (narrative) sequel?
Sonic Chronicles.
Gender: Male
Country: Canadian
1. What are your personal favorite 3 Sonic games?
SA2:Battle SADX:Directors Cut and... maybe Sonic CD?
2. What are your least favorite 3 Sonic games?
Secret Rings, Lost World, and Sonic Runners.
3. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the best?
S3&K, CD, and S2.
4. What 3 Sonic games do you think are the worst?
Secret Rings, Lost World, and (tho' Ive never play) Free Riders.
5. What Sonic game do you think is over hyped?
Lost World.
6. What Sonic game was the most disappointing for you?
Sonic 06.
7. What was your first Sonic game?
Sonic Adventure 2 Battle.
8. What is your favorite(s) Sonic gameplay style (2D platformer, “Boost-to-win”, pet sim, RPG, etc.)?
Adventure/06-style 3D Platformer by a long shot. But I've genuinely enjoyed them all other than Secret Ring's "On rails" style.
9. What 3 gameplay styles would you like to see the Sonic brand go/return to?
Adventure-style 3D Platformer (with modern polish of course), Chao Garden sim, and the boost games (maybe with a momentum system).
10. Which game incarnation of Sonic (Classic, Modern, Boom) is your favorite (stylistically)?
Modern, but I do like classic Sonic. Really not a fan of Boom at all.
11. Which incarnation of Sonic would you like to see return, or what new art style would you like to see?
I'd like to see a merging of the Classic and modern styles, like the Sonic Nendoroid
12. How many years have you been a Sonic fan?
10ish years.
13. What Sonic product/people brought you to the franchise?
Only had two tv channels and no game systems as a young kid, so finding a random episode of Sonic X one day lured me into the series, and a copy of the VHS Sonic OVA which I would rent every chance I got- got me hooked.
14. Who are your top 3 favorite Sonic characters?
Shadow, Blaze, and Emerl.
15. Who are you top 3 Sonic villians?
Chaos, Eggman, and Metal Sonic.
16. Which game villain(s) (excluding Eggman) would you like to see return?
Mephlise as Time Eater would be pretty awesome.
17. Which 3 enemy types are your favorite (Classic Badnicks, Black Arms, Egg Pawns, etc.)
Gizoids, E-100s, and GUN mechs.
18. Which, if any, entities (characters, locations, etc.) from other Sonic media would you want to see in the games?
The freedom fighters would be a cool addition to an RPG Sonic game. (Sonic Chronicles 2)
19. What Sonic product lines (games, shows, comics, etc.) do you purchase/participate in?
I buy most games, I've collected the pre-Nu Archie!Sonic comics, I have a few plushes, figures, and the pix'n'love, and I watch all the shows.
20. What is your favorite Sonic series (Archie, Boom, X, OVA, Sega!Sonic, etc)?
OVA.
21. How many Sonic games have you played? 39ish
22. How many Sonic games have you owned? 41ish
23. How many Sonic games have you completed the campaign (All Chaos Emeralds, Final Chapter, etc.)? 28.
24. How many Sonic games have you %100ed (All A Ranks, All Emblems, etc.)? only 1 I believe.
25. Are you more likely to pre-order/ buy a Sonic game in the month of release, or wait? I tend to buy main series in the first month if I have the console. otherwise I wait for Steam sales and discount bins.
26. Which game consoles (including handhelds,) do you own?
DS lite, Gameboy SP, Gamecube, PC, Wii, WiiU.
27. Which console do you have the most Sonic games for?
Gamecube.
28. Have you ever bought a console because of a Sonic game?
No. But when I do buy a system, its Sonic are usually some of the first games I buy.
29. How do you interpret the Sonic canon (consider the classic games a different universe, believe in the distinction of two worlds in the Sonic universe, consider spin off games non-canon, hold Japanese instruction manuals over American, etc.)?
I consider all Sonic games (excluding Boom) to be one canon, which of course requires some fudging.
Generally I hold Japanese canon over Western, main series over spin-offs and hand held, and SA1&2, Battle, Shadow, and Chronicles over all else.
Still trying to wrap my head around the whole "two worlds" debacle. For the time being I'm ignoring it, but I'll eventually sit down and try to plot out the canon with the idea of there being two planets in mind.
30. What is your preferred name for Sonic’s world(s) (Earth, Mobius, Planet Freedom, etc)?
Earth.
31. What is the average amount of time you put into Sonic games? (not in a sitting, but over all)
Under 10. probably about 7.
32. What Sonic have you clocked the most time into (state the amount)?
Both of the Sonic Adventure games I suspect I have over 300 hours.
33. Where do you see the Sonic franchise in ten years?
I see it more-or-less how it is now, whith a mix of good and bad games that keep Sonic alive, but not a big name in gaming.
I also suspect that no-matter how good Sonic games get, the baggage behind the name will mar the series.
34. If you had the opportunity to give the Sonic brand to a different developer which would it be, if any?
Out of curiosity I'd like to see a Nintendo Sonic game, but generally I'd prefer Sonic Team keep the franchise.
35. What is your favorite interpretation of Sonic’s characterization?
I always liked his over-the-top-cheesy 90's cool kid vibe. Sonic OVA probably got him best IMO.
36. What do you feel is Sonic’s current characterization?
I feel that Sonic has lost a great deal of his edge. With his aloof/jerkish behavior being replaced with pure heroism and bad jokes.
37. How many, if any, Sonic games are in your top ten favorite video games?
Sonic Adventure 1&2 for sure.
38. What has been your favorite Sonic cross-over/cameo to date (TMNT, Spawn, Zelda, etc)?
Sonic in Smash Bros.
39. Which Sonic game/show has your favorite Soundtrack?
Unleashed, if I had to pick.
40. What is are your 3 favorite Sonic song (stage music counts)?
Endless Possibilities, Supporting Me, and maybe... Escape from the City?
41. What other video game franchise would you consider Sonic Team's greatest competition for your attention?
Right now, the entire Nintendo Roster.
I've been putting allot of my gaming purchases Into virtual Console games instead of Sonic games missing in my library.
42. What are your top 3 Sonic locations?
43. What 3 Sonic zones would you like to see return in a Sonic game?
44. With what Sonic game have you encountered the most bugs?
Sonic Heroes. I feel like I might be the only person to have had an absolutely glitch-ridden copy of this game.
45. What Sonic game do you think deserves a (narrative) sequel?
Sonic Chronicles.
If you have any questions you think should be on the list, please mention them for my consideration!
TLDR: I got some Qs for you all. Thanks to all who answer!
Update 1:
-Questions numbered and bolded.
-Questions 42-45 added.
-Q.31 typo fixed
-Q.10&32 clarified
-Q.40 bumped from 1 song to 3
-Reddit version is on hold